P1 screen protector? Boxwave ClearTouch vs MF Overlay Plus vs InvisibleShield

[Ja_guy]

I have done some extensive browsing reading reviews and the like on these 3 screen protectors. I am ordering my P1 soon and I need the best screen protector possible with little or no loss to screen clarity and sensitivity. Also one that repels dust and fingerprints very well.

All 3 products received all round good reviews. Two of the 3 sites offer demo videos as well. Each proposes to offer the best protection. Some stood out more than others such as the InvisibleShield. It seemed rather strong (see:http://www.untenohana.com/archives/videos/ipod_scratch_test/fan_video.html). I can attest to the Boxwave being decent as it use it on my Canon Powershot SD750. But I think I may want to try something else.

The 3 contenders:

1. MartinFields Overlay Plus (http://"http://www.overlayplus.com/US/dis_product.asp?model=SE_P1&modeln=P1&prod_type=screen") :
http://aycu21.webshots.com/image/38020/2002970867634276755_rs.jpg (http://allyoucanupload.webshots.com/v/2002970867634276755)



Crystal Clear
Super Thin-0.2mm
UV Protection
High Scratch Resistance
No bubbles,easy to apply
Washable and reusable


2. Boxwave (http://"http://www.boxwave.com/products/cleartouch/cleartouch-screen-protector-sony-ericsson-p1i_2822.htm"):

http://aycu31.webshots.com/image/37870/2002978935072288223_rs.jpg (http://allyoucanupload.webshots.com/v/2002978935072288223)



Dust Repelling
Bubble-free Application
Fingerprint Free
Sized to specifically fit the Sony Ericsson P1i
Improves Handwriting Recognition
Reduces 90% of UV Rays Caused by Reflected Light, Protecting your Eyes
Isn't flimsy, but made from firmer high-grade thermoplastics designed for durability
Washable and Reusable
Protects Sensitive Touchscreen against Scratches
Includes a ClearTouch Applicator
Includes a micro-fiber cleaning cloth


3. InvisibleShield (http://"https://www.shieldzone.com/item_description/SONP1I.html");

http://aycu21.webshots.com/image/38100/2002979041850236172_rs.jpg (http://allyoucanupload.webshots.com/v/2002979041850236172)


Scratch Proof Film
Invisible Protection
Lifetime Guarantee
Free Shipping


As you can see these are 3 very good contenders. I am pleased with the Boxwave on my camera but the boxwave is the priciest of the lot. The Invisibleshield seems rather impressive though and the demo videos displaying it is almost impenetrable is a very good selling point. Also love that they have a full bodied version for the P1 as well.


I know many of you have used the above. Can I get some feedback? Would also be nice if someone has used one or more and can give personal opinion.

Thanks.


P.S. All images are representational.

[wickedass]

well these screen protectors are not available everywhere...for eg New Delhi , India. after using abt 3 different brands of screen protectors of different prices i feel that they are pretty much the same and u shud buy the cheapest one.

[mobick]

yeah i agree with that....even a cheap screen protector can actually protect your screen from scratches....not unless you really need the added "features" like those uv protection thingy :D